Skip to content
Vest-Estate-Law-Logo-White
  • Areas of Estate LawExpand
    • Estate AdministrationExpand
      • Grant of Administration
    • Estate PlanningExpand
      • Enduring Power of Attorney
      • Personal Directives
      • Will Planning
    • Estate LitigationExpand
      • Contesting a Will
      • Elder Law
      • Estate Mediation
      • Estates & Trusts
      • Guardianship & Trusteeship
    • Grant of Probate
    • Advanced Care Planning
    • Business Owner Retirement Planning
    • Business Succession Planning
    • Charitable Giving
    • Digital Assets Upon Death
    • Testamentary Trust
  • Locations & TeamExpand
    • Meet Your Team
    • Locations
    • Contact Us
  • Knowledge CentreExpand
    • Alberta Family Law
    • Estate Planning Info
    • Wills Deep Dive
    • Estate Administration
    • Probate Help
    • Calgary Articles
    • Edmonton Articles
    • Vancouver Articles
Get Help Now
Vest-Estate-Law-Logo-White

When is a Relationship “Marriage-Like” Under the Law in BC?

Hours Updated onMarch 6, 2025 Categories BC
When is a Relationship Marriage-Like Under the Law in BC

Hill v. Dhanda Overview

In the case of Hill v. Dhanda, the Supreme Court of British Columbia addressed the question of whether Tiena Hill was the spouse of Mukhtiar “Mike” Dhanda at the time of his death in June 2022. Mike passed away without a will, leaving behind two sons, Jayden and Jordan. Tiena sought a declaration that she was Mike’s spouse under the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA), which would allow her to inherit a significant portion of his estate. The defendants, who are the legal guardians of Mike’s children, opposed this claim.

Why This Decision is Important

This decision is significant for understanding how courts determine whether a relationship qualifies as a marriage-like partnership under the law. It highlights the factors considered in evaluating intimate relationships, particularly in cases where one partner is deceased and cannot provide evidence of their intentions. The ruling also addresses issues related to cohabitation, financial support, and the complexities of modern relationships.

Case Details

  • Parties Involved: Tiena Hill (Plaintiff) vs. Gurpinderjit Singh Lally and Sadaugar Singh Dhanda (Defendants, acting as guardians for Jayden and Jordan Dhanda).
  • Background:
    • Tiena and Mike began dating in May 2015.
    • Mike had two sons from a previous marriage and was their sole guardian.
    • They lived together at various properties from September 2015 until Mike’s death.
  • Legal Framework: The court evaluated whether Tiena and Mike lived in a marriage-like relationship for at least two years before his death according to WESA.

Outcome

The court ruled in favour of Tiena Hill, declaring that she had lived with Mike Dhanda in a marriage-like relationship for at least two years before his death. This entitles her to a significant portion of his estate, while Jayden and Jordan will inherit the remainder as their father’s descendants.

Key Takeaways

  • Tiena and Mike began living together in September 2015 and maintained their relationship until his death.
  • The court assessed both subjective intentions and objective evidence when determining the nature of their relationship.
  • Key indicators included cohabitation, financial support, shared responsibilities regarding Mike’s children, and social activities.
  • The ruling emphasizes that declarations of marital status on tax documents do not solely define the nature of a relationship.
  • This case illustrates the importance of holistic assessments in determining spousal relationships under the law.

References

https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2025/2025bcsc333/2025bcsc333.html
Hill v Dhanda, 2025 BCSC 333 (CanLII), <https://canlii.ca/t/k9tfd>, retrieved on 2025-03-06

Vest BC Map

Our main hub for British Columbia is located in the heart of Vancouver. That said, we serve the entire province of BC. We have the infrastructure to work with any of our clients virtually — even in the furthest regions of British Columbia.

Call (604) 256-7152 [toll free 1 (877) 415-1484] to get routed to the best representative to serve you or contact us online to schedule an appointment.

We also have a dedicated intake form to help you get the ball rolling. Our intake team will review your specific case and advise you on the next steps to take and what to expect moving forward.

Our offices are generally open 8:30 a.m.—4:30 p.m., Mon—Fri.

Vest-Estate-Law-EndStamp
Preet Mandair - Vest Estate Law

Preet Mandair

WILLS and ESTATES LAWYER

Preet’s practice focuses primarily on estate litigation. Preet is dedicated to providing practical and strategic advice to all clients in all aspects of estate litigation by understanding and assessing each client’s unique needs and advocating for her clients in a methodical and effective manner.

  • Learn More About Preet
We're here to help you
Landing Page - General

Wills / Estate Planning

Estate Administration (for Executors and Administrators)

Includes all aspects of finalizing an estate, dealing with the assets and debts of an estate and distribution to beneficiaries.
Many personal representatives (executors) request that estate administration lawyers administer the estate for them.

Estate Litigation (Dispute Resolution)

Estate litigation includes dispute of a will,  making a claim against the estate as a spouse of the deceased, disinheritance, or if you think there has been undue influence in the process of making a will.

Our estate litigation lawyers act for personal representatives (executors), administrators, beneficiaries, spouses and adult interdependent partners (“AIP”) of a deceased individual.

Adult Guardianship and Trustee Applications

More Details / Other Concerns

Is there any other information you would like to include? If so, please provide us with a brief description

Recent Posts

  • Beyond Your BC Estate: Properties That Bypass Your WillMay 18, 2025
  • Estate Strategies for BC’s Blended FamiliesMay 17, 2025
  • How BC Courts Can Validate Invalid Wills Under WESA Section 58May 16, 2025

Dedicated estate litigators

Whether you need estate mediation or a court decision – Vest has the team to bring you a favourable outcome.

Estate Disputes Happen - Get Help Here
The Canadian Bar Association
Law Society of Alberta
Law Society of British Columbia
Three Best Rated Award
Calgary Best Rated Badge
Protect your estate
Join Team Vest!

We're looking for highly motivated associates to join our busy team.
Vest Estate Law offers competitive compensation and a spirited corporate culture.

Click Here for more info
EDMONTON

Suite 400, 10216 124 Street, Edmonton, Alberta T5N 4A3
Local: (587) 442-3553
Toll-Free: 1 (877) 448-3131

CALGARY

Suite 700, 396 11 Ave SW, Calgary, Alberta T2R 0C5
Local: (403) 226-9757
Toll-Free: 1 (888) 382-0033

VANCOUVER

Suite 301, 134 Abbott Street Vancouver, BC V6B 2K4
Local: (604) 256-7152
Toll-Free: 1 (877) 415-1484

RED DEER

Suite 203, 4807 50 Avenue, Red Deer, Alberta T4N 4A5
Local: (587) 441-3770

MORE

Contact Us
Payments
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Disclaimer



© 2025 Vest Estate Lawyers. Vest Estate Lawyers is a registered trade name of Spectrum Family Law LLP / Taylor Janis LLP - Sitemap

Facebook Linkedin Instagram

Do you have an estate issue that requires assistance?

Our estate-focused paralegals are standing by to assist you.

Get Help Here
  • Areas of Estate Law
    • Estate Administration
      • Grant of Administration
    • Estate Planning
      • Enduring Power of Attorney
      • Personal Directives
      • Will Planning
    • Estate Litigation
      • Contesting a Will
      • Elder Law
      • Estate Mediation
      • Estates & Trusts
      • Guardianship & Trusteeship
    • Grant of Probate
    • Advanced Care Planning
    • Business Owner Retirement Planning
    • Business Succession Planning
    • Charitable Giving
    • Digital Assets Upon Death
    • Testamentary Trust
  • Locations & Team
    • Meet Your Team
    • Locations
    • Contact Us
  • Knowledge Centre
    • Alberta Family Law
    • Estate Planning Info
    • Wills Deep Dive
    • Estate Administration
    • Probate Help
    • Calgary Articles
    • Edmonton Articles
    • Vancouver Articles